Choosing between celebrity makeup palettes is less about the famous name on the box and more about whether the shades suit your style, skill level, and routine. I’d start with ColourPop x The Twilight Saga New Moon for the broadest mix of finishes and everyday-to-dramatic flexibility. The r.e.m. Beauty Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest palette stands out for its rich earthy and jewel-toned color story, while ColourPop x The Twilight Saga Eclipse makes the most sense for shoppers who want a moody, collectible 15-pan palette with a strongly pigmented look.
Get movie nights delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Those differences shape the ranking: New Moon takes the lead for its combination of shade count and finish variety, with the caveat that some shades may need layering. r.e.m. Beauty is the more concentrated, high-impact option, but its smaller shade range and complex finishes can ask more of a beginner. Eclipse offers similarly broad styling potential to New Moon, yet its limited-edition status and smaller stated weight make it a less straightforward everyday pick. I’m comparing these palettes as celebrity-collaboration buys, where theme, usability, and formula tradeoffs all matter.
Key Takeaways
- New Moon is my best overall pick for buyers who want 15 shades spanning matte, shimmer, and metallic glitter finishes, though a few colors may need extra layering.
- The r.e.m. Beauty Wicked palette is the strongest choice for bold, rich color in a compact 12-shade edit, but its duochromes and glitters may take more blending confidence.
- Eclipse suits Twilight fans who want a collectible, moody 15-pan color story and stronger stated pigmentation, with less room for buyers seeking a broad neutral wardrobe.
- New Moon and Eclipse both offer 15 shades, but the listed finishes and stated performance make New Moon the more versatile everyday-to-evening option and Eclipse the more dramatic-leaning one.
- All three palettes are theme-led rather than neutral basics; buyers who need a simple, beginner-focused set of everyday shades may be better served by a less character-driven palette.
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga New Moon Eye Shadow Palette |  | Best Overall — the most adaptable mix of shades and finishes | Number of shades: 15 | Size: 0.6 oz | Finishes: Matte, shimmer, metallic glitter | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| r.e.m. Beauty by Ariana Grande Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest Eyeshadow Palette, 12 Shades |  | Best for Rich Color — a focused edit with varied specialty finishes | Number of shades: 12 | Formulas: Matte, duochrome, shimmer, glitter | Color inspiration: Ozian Forest | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga Eclipse Eyeshadow Palette – Limited Edition, 15 Shades |  | Best for Twilight Collectors — a moody, pigment-forward 15-pan option | Number of shades: 15 | Weight: 0.63 oz | Finishes: Matte, metallic, glitter | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| celebrity makeup palette | Number of shades | Collection | Size | Finishes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga | 15 | ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: New Moon | 0.6 oz | Matte, shimmer, metallic glitter |
| r.e.m. Beauty by Ariana Grande | 12 | Wicked: For Good | Not specified | — |
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga | 15 | ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: Eclipse | — | Matte, metallic, glitter |
More Details on Our Top Picks
ColourPop x The Twilight Saga New Moon Eye Shadow Palette
New Moon earns my best overall spot because its 15-pan format and mix of matte, shimmer, and metallic glitter finishes provide more ways to build a look than a narrowly themed palette. The balance suits someone who wants to move from a softer daytime eye to a deeper, more theatrical finish without switching palettes. Its Twilight-inspired mood gives the shades a recognizable identity, but the finish variety is what makes it a practical collaboration rather than only a fan keepsake.
Compared with the 12-shade r.e.m. Beauty Wicked palette, New Moon gives buyers three more pans and a simpler finish brief. Wicked adds duochromes and is described as highly pigmented, which may appeal to someone seeking richer color effects, but can be trickier to handle. New Moon’s stated combination of everyday wear and dramatic looks makes it the easier all-rounder. Against ColourPop’s Eclipse palette, it offers a similarly sized 15-shade collection, while its stated matte, shimmer, and metallic-glitter mix keeps the styling proposition broad.
The tradeoff is that breadth does not guarantee strong color payoff in every pan. The supplied details note that some shades may be less pigmented and require multiple layers for intensity, so shoppers who want immediate, saturated color may prefer r.e.m. Beauty or Eclipse. The formula is described as long-wearing and fallout-resistant, and the palette is vegan and cruelty-free, useful features for buyers who prioritize wear claims and those product standards. I’d still treat those as stated attributes rather than a promise that every shade behaves identically.
Who should choose it: someone who wants a celebrity collaboration that can support several levels of drama, values a mix of textures, and likes the Twilight theme. Who should skip it: someone who wants uniformly bold payoff with minimal layering, or a straightforward neutral palette without glitter. New Moon ranks above the other two because its mix of size, texture options, and stated day-to-night flexibility is the strongest fit for the widest range of buyers.
Pros:- 15 shades provide more room to combine colors than the 12-pan Wicked palette.
- Matte, shimmer, and metallic glitter finishes support both understated and dramatic looks.
- The formula is described as long-wearing and fallout-resistant.
- Vegan and cruelty-free according to the supplied product details.
Cons:- Some shades may be less pigmented and need several layers for strong color.
- Limited-edition availability may make it harder to replace later.
- Metallic glitter is not a fit for shoppers who prefer an all-matte palette.
Best for: Makeup shoppers who want a Twilight-themed 15-shade palette with matte, shimmer, and metallic glitter options for softer and more dramatic eye looks.
Not ideal for: Buyers who expect every shade to deliver intense color in one pass, avoid glitter, or want a plain neutral palette without a strong entertainment theme.
- Number of shades:15
- Size:0.6 oz
- Finishes:Matte, shimmer, metallic glitter
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Collection:ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: New Moon
- Availability note:Limited edition, while supplies last
Our verdict“I recommend New Moon as the most versatile celebrity palette here, provided you’re comfortable building up some shades and enjoy glitter finishes.”
r.e.m. Beauty by Ariana Grande Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest Eyeshadow Palette, 12 Shades
The Wicked: For Good Ozian Forest palette is my pick for rich, focused color rather than maximum shade count. Its 12 shades combine earthy and jewel-toned hues, with mattes, shimmers, duochromes, and glitters. That combination gives it a distinctive range of effects: the earthy shades can ground a look, while jewel tones and shifting finishes create a more expressive result. The palette’s identity is more overtly color-driven than New Moon’s broader everyday-to-dramatic pitch.
Its strongest stated advantage over both ColourPop palettes is high pigmentation and blendability. For a shopper who likes visible color and already knows how to work with different textures, that makes the compact edit appealing. New Moon has 15 shades and is positioned for more everyday flexibility, so it is the safer pick if you want more room to experiment across a larger color selection. Eclipse is also a 15-pan option and is described as highly pigmented, but the Wicked palette has the clearest four-finish breakdown, including duochromes.
That variety also creates the main drawback. Duochromes and glitters can call for a more considered application than a straightforward matte-and-shimmer palette, and the supplied description specifically flags that complex shades may challenge beginners. With only 12 shades, the palette has less breadth than either ColourPop option; shoppers seeking a large collection of everyday neutrals may not find enough range here. Product size and packaging details are not provided, so I would not choose it based on assumptions about portability or construction.
Who should choose it: an Ariana Grande or Wicked fan who wants vivid, earthy-to-jewel tones and enjoys working with multiple finishes. Who should skip it: a beginner looking for the simplest blending experience, or a shopper who wants a larger set of dependable neutral shades. I rank it second because its described payoff and finish variety are compelling, but its smaller, more specialized color story is not as broadly flexible as New Moon.
Pros:- The 12 shades cover earthy and jewel-toned colors in a focused palette.
- Includes matte, duochrome, shimmer, and glitter formulas.
- Described as highly pigmented and blendable.
- Offers a more specialized finish mix than the two ColourPop palettes.
Cons:- Fewer shades than either 15-pan ColourPop option.
- Complex finishes may take more skill to blend and place.
- Product size and packaging details are not listed in the supplied specifications.
Best for: Wicked and Ariana Grande fans who prefer richly pigmented earthy and jewel-toned shades, and are comfortable blending mattes, duochromes, shimmers, and glitter.
Not ideal for: Beginners who want uncomplicated blending, shoppers who need more than 12 shades, or anyone who prioritizes confirmed size and packaging information.
- Number of shades:12
- Formulas:Matte, duochrome, shimmer, glitter
- Color inspiration:Ozian Forest
- Brand:r.e.m. beauty
- Collection:Wicked: For Good
- Color range:Earthy and jewel-toned shades
- Size:Not specified
Our verdict“I’d choose the Wicked palette for a compact, high-impact color story and varied finishes, not as the easiest or most broadly neutral option.”
ColourPop x The Twilight Saga Eclipse Eyeshadow Palette – Limited Edition, 15 Shades
Eclipse is the most collector-oriented pick in this trio: its limited-edition Twilight tie-in and moody 15-shade story are a natural match for fans who want the collaboration to feel distinctive, not interchangeable with an everyday neutral palette. The listed matte, metallic, and glitter finishes leave room for both softer styling and more dramatic looks, while the supplied description emphasizes strong pigmentation, long wear, and smooth blendability.
Compared with New Moon, Eclipse has the same number of shades but a slightly different case for buying. New Moon’s description stresses everyday-to-dramatic versatility and includes shimmer alongside matte and metallic glitter. Eclipse is positioned more squarely around a moody color story and stronger stated pigment. If a buyer wants a flexible palette first, New Moon is the more convincing choice; if the theme and more intense color direction matter more, Eclipse has the clearer identity. Compared with r.e.m. Beauty’s 12 shades, Eclipse offers three additional pans, although Wicked provides a specifically listed duochrome finish absent from Eclipse’s supplied specs.
The downside is that a tightly themed palette may have less everyday range than its shade count suggests. The provided cons also flag limited shade variety for some users, and the listed weight is 0.63 oz, described as small enough that frequent reapplication may be needed. Since weight alone does not explain how much product is used per look, I treat that as a practical caution rather than a guarantee. Its limited-edition status adds collectible appeal but can make replacement less certain.
Who should choose it: a Twilight fan who likes moody colors, wants 15 shades, and values the stated blendability and pigment emphasis. Who should skip it: shoppers who want a broad set of conventional neutrals, dislike limited-edition buying, or prefer the most clearly supported everyday versatility. It ranks third because its appeal is strongest for a defined fan-and-color preference, while New Moon serves more styling needs and Wicked offers a more unusual finish mix.
Pros:- 15 shades offer a larger edit than the r.e.m. Beauty Wicked palette.
- Matte, metallic, and glitter finishes allow variation in texture.
- The formula is described as highly pigmented, long-wearing, and easy to blend.
- Limited-edition collectible presentation suits Twilight fans.
Cons:- The color range may feel limited for shoppers seeking broader variety.
- The listed 0.63 oz size may not suit buyers concerned about frequent reapplication.
- Limited-edition availability may complicate replacing a favorite shade or palette.
Best for: Twilight fans who want a collectible, moody 15-shade palette with matte, metallic, and glitter textures and a pigment-forward look.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need a broad everyday neutral range, prefer a product they can readily replace, or want explicit duochrome options.
- Number of shades:15
- Weight:0.63 oz
- Finishes:Matte, metallic, glitter
- Collection:ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: Eclipse
- Formula claims:Long-wearing, highly pigmented, blendable
- Cruelty-free:Yes
- Availability note:Limited edition
Our verdict“Eclipse is the strongest fan-focused choice here, but I’d favor New Moon for wider everyday flexibility and Wicked for more varied specialty finishes.”
How We Picked
I ranked these three products around the question behind a celebrity makeup palette search: which collaboration is most likely to earn a place in a buyer’s routine, rather than only look appealing as a collectible? I compared their shade-count and finish mix, the range of looks each description supports, the formula claims provided, and the practical limitations buyers may face. Because the lineup consists of two Twilight palettes and one Wicked palette, I also weighed how clearly each palette’s theme translates into wearable or distinctive color choices.
New Moon ranks first because its 15 shades and matte, shimmer, and metallic glitter finishes offer a useful balance for both softer and more dramatic eye looks. That advantage is tempered by reports that some shades may need multiple layers and can be less pigmented. I placed the r.e.m. Beauty palette second: its 12 shades are described as highly pigmented and blendable, and it has the most explicit mix of mattes, shimmers, duochromes, and glitters. Its tighter shade range and potentially demanding finishes make it more specialized than New Moon. Eclipse comes third, not because it lacks appeal, but because its value is most distinctive for Twilight collectors and shoppers who favor a moody, more pigment-forward look.
I use product information supplied for this comparison and do not treat unlisted details as proof of performance. For example, the Wicked palette has no stated size or packaging details, and I don’t infer them. The ordering reflects versatility, ease of choosing, stated formula characteristics, and audience fit, not celebrity status alone. Each pick has a clear buyer in mind and a meaningful reason another shopper might prefer a different palette.
| celebrity makeup palette | Finishes | Collection | Availability note |
|---|---|---|---|
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga | Matte, shimmer, metallic glitter | ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: New Moon | Limited edition, while supplies last |
| r.e.m. Beauty by Ariana Grande | — | Wicked: For Good | — |
| ColourPop x The Twilight Saga | Matte, metallic, glitter | ColourPop x The Twilight Saga: Eclipse | Limited edition |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Celebrity Makeup Palettes
I’d choose among these palettes by deciding which matters most: versatility, vivid color, or fan-focused theme. Shade count is a useful starting point, but it does not tell you how often you will use the colors or whether the finishes match your habits.
Decide how much everyday range you need
New Moon and Eclipse both contain 15 shades, compared with 12 in the Wicked palette. That does not automatically make either ColourPop option more useful; it means they offer more pans to work with. New Moon is the clearest all-round choice because its description explicitly spans everyday and dramatic looks. Eclipse also gives a larger selection, but its moody theme may be less adaptable if your daily routine relies on soft, familiar neutrals. Wicked’s smaller selection can be a plus if you prefer a curated edit over a larger palette, though buyers who want many transition shades may find it limiting.
Before choosing, think about the looks you actually want to create. If you want one palette to cover subtle color and evening drama, New Moon has the strongest stated case. If you routinely wear deep, expressive shades, Eclipse or Wicked may feel more purpose-built. If you mainly need neutral basics, none of these theme-led collaborations is an obvious substitute for a dedicated neutral palette.
Match the finish mix to your routine
All three palettes mix textures, but their finish profiles are not identical. New Moon lists matte, shimmer, and metallic glitter. Eclipse lists matte, metallic, and glitter. Wicked adds duochrome to matte, shimmer, and glitter, creating the broadest explicitly stated set of finish types. That matters because a palette with specialty finishes can deliver more visual variety, but may require extra care when you want a blended, low-key result.
If you rarely wear glitter or prefer a simple matte look, do not let a celebrity collaboration or collectible theme push you toward finishes you will leave unused. For buyers who enjoy experimentation, Wicked’s duochromes offer the most distinct texture proposition. For a more familiar combination, New Moon’s matte-and-shimmer foundation with glitter accents may be easier to incorporate into regular looks.
Think about color payoff and application confidence
The supplied descriptions position Wicked as highly pigmented and blendable, while Eclipse is described as highly pigmented and easy to blend. New Moon’s formula is described as long-wearing and fallout-resistant, but its listed drawbacks say some shades may be less pigmented and may need multiple layers. If you want color to build gradually, that can be workable; if you prefer strong payoff quickly, Wicked or Eclipse may align better with your stated preference.
More pigment is not automatically easier for a new user. Deep, bold colors and specialty finishes can be harder to control than softer shades, and the Wicked product details flag that some complex shades may challenge beginners. If you are still learning placement and blending, New Moon’s broader everyday-to-dramatic positioning may be a gentler starting point, although its shade-by-shade payoff may vary. Choose based on your comfort with application, not just the strongest formula claim.
Weigh theme and collectibility against repeat use
These are collaborations tied to recognizable entertainment properties: Twilight’s New Moon, Twilight’s Eclipse, and Wicked: For Good. A strong theme can make a palette more appealing to a fan, and Eclipse explicitly highlights collectible limited-edition packaging. New Moon is also described as limited edition, while Wicked is associated with the Ozian Forest collection. Those ties are part of the product’s appeal, but they do not replace a usable shade mix.
I’d ask whether you would still want the colors if the collaboration name were not printed on the palette. If the answer is yes, the purchase has a stronger chance of fitting your routine as well as your collection. If the draw is mainly the franchise, think of that as a separate reason to buy and be realistic about limited-edition availability. Do not assume that a product will be restocked or easy to replace when no such detail is supplied.
Check the details you can verify
New Moon lists a size of 0.6 oz, and Eclipse lists a weight of 0.63 oz. The Wicked palette’s supplied specifications do not include size or packaging details. If portability, amount of product, or package construction is a deciding factor, compare confirmed listing information before choosing rather than filling gaps with assumptions. The available details also distinguish the palettes on product claims: New Moon is listed as vegan and cruelty-free, while Eclipse is listed as cruelty-free; no comparable vegan claim is supplied for Wicked.
Make your shortlist from the facts that matter to you: shade count, listed finishes, color direction, stated formula characteristics, and any values or product information you require. The most suitable celebrity palette is the one whose color story and use case fit your habits, not the one with the most elaborate theme or the longest finish list.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which of these celebrity makeup palettes is the most versatile?
I’d choose ColourPop x The Twilight Saga New Moon for the broadest stated versatility. Its 15 shades combine matte, shimmer, and metallic glitter finishes, and the product description says the palette can support everyday or dramatic looks. Eclipse also has 15 shades, but its appeal leans more moody and collectible. Wicked offers a distinctive four-finish mix, yet its 12 shades make it a more focused edit.
Which palette is the best choice for a beginner?
New Moon is the most plausible starting point if you want a themed palette with multiple ways to style the shades, but it is not a guaranteed beginner palette: some shades may need layering, and it includes metallic glitter. Wicked may demand more blending confidence because its duochromes and glitters are described as potentially challenging for beginners. I’d choose based on your comfort with varied textures and start with simpler matte or shimmer shades.
Which palette offers the most varied finishes?
The r.e.m. Beauty Wicked: For Good palette has the broadest explicitly listed finish mix: matte, duochrome, shimmer, and glitter. New Moon lists matte, shimmer, and metallic glitter, while Eclipse lists matte, metallic, and glitter. If specialty texture is your priority, Wicked has the clearest advantage, though its 12-shade count is lower than the two ColourPop palettes.
Are the Twilight palettes interchangeable?
No. Both ColourPop palettes have 15 shades and a Twilight connection, but their stated positioning differs. New Moon is framed around a mix that can work for everyday and dramatic looks, with some shades potentially needing layers. Eclipse has a moody direction and is described as highly pigmented and blendable, with collectible limited-edition appeal. I’d pick by color mood and expected use, not by the franchise name alone.
Which palette should I choose if I want bold color?
The Wicked palette and Eclipse are the stronger matches based on the supplied formula descriptions: Wicked is described as highly pigmented, and Eclipse is described as highly pigmented with smooth application and blendability. Wicked brings earthy and jewel-toned shades with duochromes; Eclipse offers a moody Twilight-inspired story. New Moon can also create dramatic looks, but its details warn that some shades may need multiple layers to reach strong intensity.
Conclusion
Choose New Moon if you want the best balance of shade count, familiar finishes, and everyday-to-dramatic flexibility. Pick the r.e.m. Beauty Wicked palette if you are an Ariana Grande or Wicked fan who wants a compact, vivid color story with duochromes and does not mind a more involved application. Choose Eclipse if your priority is a moody Twilight collectible with 15 shades and a stated emphasis on pigment and blendability. I’d skip all three in favor of a neutral-focused palette if your main goal is a simple, low-glitter everyday set; these picks are most rewarding when their entertainment-inspired themes and distinctive colors are part of the appeal.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
